For years, energy suppliers in the UK spoke about “high-usage households” as if they were a niche category — large families, electric-only homes, or those running home-based businesses. Yet, in 2025, even modest households are being flagged by supplier algorithms as high consumption.
The result is a silent shift where average consumers — those who once fell squarely in the “medium user” bracket — are being priced, profiled, and pressured like energy-heavy homes. Many are now using tools to compare energy prices just to check whether their bills still match their actual usage.
This quiet squeeze is reshaping what the “average household” means and raising bills in ways that many people don’t yet understand.
Why Are Average Households Suddenly Seen as High-Usage?
The change comes down to a mix of forecasting models, supplier risk management, and outdated data.
Energy suppliers base your direct debit and tariff quotes not just on your actual meter readings but also on expected usage profiles designed by Ofgem and refined by each company’s internal algorithms.
When wholesale gas prices jump or when weather models predict colder winters, those algorithms inflate the estimated consumption — even if you haven’t used more energy.
For example, a home using 2,900 kWh of electricity and 12,000 kWh of gas a year (the Ofgem “medium” profile) may now be reclassified as “above average” by some suppliers, who assume future spikes in demand.
This leads to:
- Higher monthly direct debits “for safety”
- Increased standing charges to “cover supplier risk”
- Pressure to move to prepayment or “smart-only” tariffs
Even if your meter shows stable usage, the system treats you as though you’re edging into high consumption.
The Psychology Behind the “Overestimate and Adjust” Approach
Suppliers argue it’s better to overestimate than undercharge — they claim it avoids “bill shock” in winter. But for households already struggling, this can feel like forced budgeting.
Direct debits rise automatically, and suppliers rarely explain that these projections aren’t based on your actual current usage. Instead, they’re shaped by regional temperature data, national averages, and wholesale energy forecasts.
The Energy Saving Trust has noted that many homes could save between £150–£260 a year by manually correcting overestimated usage or switching to tariffs that reflect genuine consumption patterns.
This is where tools like the energy bill calculator come in — they help you work out what you should be paying based on accurate kWh figures rather than inflated supplier estimates.
How Standing Charges Add to the Pressure
Another factor behind the squeeze is the increase in standing charges. Even if you use less energy, these daily fixed costs have risen across most regions.
According to Ofgem data, electricity standing charges now average around 60p per day, and gas around 31p — that’s roughly £332 a year before using a single unit of energy.
For a low-usage household, this means a much larger share of the bill is now fixed, leaving little room to save by cutting back.
This creates a paradox: households that have reduced their consumption still see higher overall costs because standing charges keep climbing.
Why “Dual Fuel” Doesn’t Always Mean Better Value
Many families choose dual fuel tariffs for simplicity — one supplier, one bill. But these deals don’t always offer the best value anymore.
With gas and electricity costs behaving differently on the wholesale market, combined contracts can lock customers into less competitive pricing for one of the fuels.
By comparing dual fuel tariffs or single-fuel tariffs, households can often find a cheaper energy supplier and reduce overall costs — especially when one provider offers better rates for gas while another has competitive electricity prices for homes with EV chargers or electric heating.
Dual fuel once meant convenience. Today, it can quietly cost more.
Smart Meters and the Data Dilemma
Smart meters were meant to fix usage accuracy problems. But some suppliers still apply inflated forecasts even when they receive real-time data.
Why? Because billing systems often use “profile classes” (e.g. domestic unrestricted, Economy 7, etc.) that assume typical usage patterns rather than reading the data dynamically.
If you’ve changed your habits — say, by running fewer appliances or adding insulation — your profile might still treat you as a heavier user.
That’s why it’s important to cross-check your actual annual usage through a comparison tool before accepting any “revised estimate”.
Checking your usage regularly with a compare energy prices tool ensures your tariff reflects your true consumption, not just a predictive model.
What You Can Do to Push Back Against Overcharging
Energy suppliers often rely on customer inaction. Once a higher direct debit is set, most people don’t question it — especially if the account remains in credit.
Here’s what you can do to stay in control:
- Check your annual consumption using last year’s bills (kWh for both fuels).
- Use an online calculator to verify what your actual cost should be.
- Submit readings monthly, even with a smart meter, to trigger recalculations.
- Challenge supplier estimates that are clearly above your typical usage.
- Switch supplier if forecasts or standing charges remain inflated — comparison sites update daily with the latest tariffs.
Suppliers are legally obliged under Ofgem rules to provide a breakdown of how your direct debit is calculated if you ask. You can request this at any time.
The Growing Gap Between Efficiency and Cost
Energy efficiency improvements should bring down bills, yet many UK homes are not seeing those savings.
For instance, households that invested in loft insulation or new boilers before 2022 expected a 15–25% drop in usage, but rising standing charges and inflated estimates have wiped out much of that benefit.
This disconnect discourages people from making further energy-saving investments, even though efficiency remains the most reliable way to cut long-term costs.
Why This Matters Beyond Winter
The “quiet squeeze” has bigger implications. If suppliers continue to inflate estimates for risk protection, the national average for “medium usage” will keep drifting upward.
That means government forecasts and price cap reviews will also shift, pushing the baseline cost of living even higher.
In effect, Britain risks normalising inflated consumption patterns — where a standard home looks “high-use” on paper, even when it’s not.
How to Get Back to Fair Billing
To restore balance, households need to base their energy plans on real numbers, not algorithmic assumptions.
- Check your last 12 months of kWh use
- Run it through an energy bill calculator
- Compare both single and dual fuel tariffs
- Question every direct debit increase that isn’t backed by usage data
Suppliers should not penalise ordinary families for forecasting errors. By keeping accurate records and using transparent comparison tools, you can reclaim control over your energy budget.
The quiet squeeze only works when people stay silent.
OTS News on Social Media