Council too slow on children’s services improvement, says Ofsted report

29th March 2023

An Ofsted report has revealed that Sefton Council’s children’s services are continuing to fail some minors who “continue to experience ongoing harm”.

The Council has faced significant criticism over the state of Children’s Services, with matters culminating in an “inadequate” Ofsted rating last year.

Southport Conservative leader Cllr Mike Prendergast said the report was “disappointing” and that “lack of accountability is astonishing.”

Meanwhile, Liberal Democrat leader Cllr John Pugh told OTS News that “given this background, one would expect resignations.”

Senior management has acknowledged failings, and improvements have been promised, but opposition critics claim that progress is not being made quickly enough.

Interim Director of Education and Children’s Services, Dr Risthardh Hare, said he was “disappointed” by the findings, that recruitment still posed a major challenge to the service.

Inspector Lisa Summers detailed in the report:

  • Sefton children’s services have made insufficient progress in improving the response to children in need of help and protection since the last inspection.
  • Recruitment and retention of social workers continue to be a significant challenge, with a high dependence on agency social workers making the service fragile.
  • Many children experience drift and delay in having their needs met, and some continue to experience ongoing harm due to weaknesses in assessments and plans.
  • Social work capacity issues are impacting on the quality and timeliness of services for disabled children.

Responding to the letter from Ofsted, Dr Risthardh Hare, Interim Director of Education and Children’s Services, said: “Whilst I acknowledge that Sefton Council Children’s Services and partners still have work to do on our improvement journey, I was pleased that Ofsted have recognised how changes over the last year are starting to make a positive difference in areas such as services for disabled children and children with complex needs, senior management oversight and stability in the workforce, which were all key elements of our initial phase of our Improvement Plan.

“There is still work to do, but we are confident that with our committed workforce and partners, the significant financial investment into Children’s Services, our ambitious plans can be delivered, and improvements made at pace.

“Improving our service is not just about improving the Ofsted rating, it’s about making sure children benefit from the best services, care and support possible, making sure they are safe, protected and inspired to reach their full potential.”

Cllr John Pugh said: “Irrespective of any administrative and political embarrassment, this is about children, many of whom are victims of neglect,  suffering more than they need to. 
“Funding has increased for this service from £33m to £73M in the space of a few years without commensurate improvements in outcome. It saddens me to say this, but given this background, one would expect resignations. 
As this is clearly a problem beyond the competence of the current Labour administration to solve, I would suggest reviving a properly functioning, cross-party Social Services Committee bringing together expertise and challenge, regardless of party. Too much that is wrong in Sefton is under the radar and decided by too few people.
The casualties of the current system are the sad neglected, children of the borough. “
Councillor Mike Prendergast said, “It is hugely disappointing to see that the main headline findings from Ofsted still state that the pace of improvement within the department is too slow and most weaknesses previously identified back in February 2022 remain today.

I have no doubt that the frontline staff are working as hard as they can, but they are being let down and paying the price for over a decade of poor management.

“At a political level, there still seems to be a failure to recognise the seriousness of the situation and an acknowledgement of the work that needs to be done to improve things and ensure that the most vulnerable children in Sefton are safe and are given the best opportunities in life.

“Too much focus is placed on small improvement that have occurred rather than the enormous challenges that remain.

“The lack of accountability is astonishing, we still have a situation where the relevant Overview & Scrutiny Committee is chaired and ran by Labour councillors, despite the fact that the situation we now find ourselves in has come about after over a decade of Labour being in power in Sefton. “