Performance problems are a normal part of running a team, but how you handle them matters. A fair, consistent approach protects both the employee and your business.
- Set Clear Expectations From the Start
Employees cannot meet standards they do not know about. Spell out what the job involves, how success is measured and what good looks like, ideally in the contract, job description and induction. Revisit objectives regularly, particularly when a role changes. Clear expectations also give you an objective yardstick later, which makes any difficult conversation easier and fairer for everyone.
- Recognise Performance Problems Early
Missed deadlines, repeated errors or a drop in quality are far easier to address early than once habits have set in. Look for patterns instead of one-off slips, and consider the cause before assuming the worst. Unclear instructions, inadequate training, workload and personal circumstances can all play a part, and some may involve health or disability, which carries legal duties for employers.
- Have Constructive Conversations With Employees
Start informally, in private, and keep the focus on facts rather than personality. Give specific examples, explain the standard you expect, and listen properly to the employee’s side. Ask what would help, whether that is training, clearer priorities or more support. Make it plain that your aim is improvement, not punishment, and agree on what will change before you finish.
- Document Concerns and Agree on Next Steps
Acas advises employers to keep a record of conversations about performance. Note the date, the issues discussed, the examples given, the employee’s response and what was agreed, then confirm it in writing. Record any support offered and set a date to review progress. Good records show you acted fairly and prevent disputes about what was said.
- Give Employees a Fair Opportunity to Improve
If informal steps do not work, a performance improvement plan can help. It should set out specific objectives, a realistic timescale and any training or support, and it should be discussed with the employee and shared in writing. Review progress regularly, acknowledge improvement and explain honestly what happens if standards are still not met. Fairness means giving genuine time and help, not simply building a case.
- Know When Formal Action May Be Necessary
If performance still does not improve, a formal capability process may follow, including the right to be accompanied at meetings and to appeal. Dismissal should be a last resort. The risks are also rising: from 1 January 2027, employees will be able to claim unfair dismissal after six months instead of two years, and the limit on compensation will be removed. Before taking formal steps, it is sensible to speak to employment lawyers so your process is sound.
Handled early, openly and fairly, most performance problems can be resolved without formal action. Where they cannot, a documented, fair process puts your business on the strongest footing.
