Sexual jokes and comments between colleagues are getting much closer attention from healthcare regulators. Here’s what the law says, and why “I didn’t mean it like that” rarely settles the matter.
Most healthcare teams run on a bit of humour. Long shifts, high pressure and close working relationships make that inevitable. Often it’s a good thing. But when jokes take a sexual turn, they can end up in front of a fitness to practise panel. And the professional who made them is often surprised to learn that “it was only banter” isn’t a defence.
A single off-colour remark won’t automatically amount to harassment. But sexual comments to a colleague can be treated as sexual harassment or sexually motivated misconduct, even where the speaker meant nothing by them. What matters is what was said, the context and the effect it had.
Regulators are paying closer attention
The Professional Standards Authority (PSA), which oversees the UK’s health and care regulators, published a report in September 2026 called Improving the handling of sexual misconduct cases in fitness to practise. It’s written for regulators rather than individual professionals, but its message is hard to miss.
According to the PSA, the share of final fitness to practise decisions involving a sexual misconduct charge rose from 9.5% in 2021/22 to 18.1% in 2024/25, before easing slightly to 16.6% in 2025/26. Around 70% of these cases that reach a substantive hearing end in suspension or striking off.
The PSA treats harassment within healthcare teams as a patient safety risk, not just a workplace dispute. It has also flagged under-charging of sexual motivation and sexual harassment as a recurring weakness, which suggests more cases will be framed that way in future.
Its definition of sexual misconduct is broad, running from inappropriate comments at one end to serious criminal behaviour at the other. Remarks about someone’s appearance, suggestive comments and intrusive questions about a colleague’s relationships all fall within it.
Effect counts, not just intent
For doctors, paragraph 57 of the GMC’s Good Medical Practice (2024) says they mustn’t act in a sexual way towards colleagues with the purpose or effect of causing offence, embarrassment, humiliation or distress. The definition of harassment in section 26 of the Equality Act 2010 works the same way: purpose or effect.
That word “effect” changes everything. If a remark was sexual and it reasonably caused distress, the speaker’s good intentions won’t make the problem go away. Other professions have their own standards, so nurses, dentists, pharmacists and allied health professionals should check their own regulator’s wording. The direction of travel is the same across the board.
Words alone can be enough
There’s a common assumption that sexual misconduct needs physical contact or explicit language. The courts disagree.
In PSA v HCPC & Yong [2021] EWHC 52 (Admin), the High Court found sexual motivation in conduct that was largely verbal: invitations to stay over, an offer of a spare room, a remark about a school uniform and an unwanted hug. The court also gave weight to colleagues describing the registrant as “flirty”. How colleagues saw the behaviour can be evidence in its own right.
Motive is inferred from the whole picture
Few people admit to a sexual motive, so panels infer it. Basson v GMC [2018] EWHC 505 (Admin) set out the test: was the conduct aimed at sexual gratification or at pursuing a future sexual relationship? The Court of Appeal in Haris v GMC [2021] EWCA Civ 763 confirmed that where there’s a strong case and no credible innocent explanation, a panel can find sexual motivation.
GMC v Dugboyele [2024] EWHC 2651 (Admin) shows how this plays out. A long pattern of behaviour towards junior female colleagues made sexual motivation more likely than not. The doctor’s explanation that he was simply being friendly wasn’t accepted.
So “I’m friendly with everyone” will be tested against everything else the panel knows. A running joke repeated over months looks very different from a one-off comment.
There are limits
None of this means every awkward remark becomes a regulatory case. The conduct has to be sexual when looked at objectively and in context. Under section 26, the effect a colleague describes also has to be a reasonable one in the circumstances.
The courts haven’t treated the Basson test as beyond question either, and the Court of Appeal in Haris left the door open to criticism of it. Where there are several complainants, PSA v GMC & Garrard [2025] EWHC 318 (Admin) says panels must rule out collusion before using one person’s account to support another’s.
Staying on the right side of the line
A few practical habits go a long way:
- keep sexual content out of workplace humour altogether
- ask whether a remark, read objectively, was sexual and could reasonably cause offence
- think about power, especially with trainees, students and newer staff
- don’t take laughter or silence as agreement (the PSA is clear that not objecting isn’t consent)
- watch for patterns, because repeated jokes add up
- if you’ve caused offence, acknowledge it quickly and sincerely
That last point matters. The PSA treats a refusal to recognise harm as a serious aggravating factor.
If a concern is raised about you
Don’t rely on intention alone. Start with the facts: exactly what was said, to whom, where and what led up to it. If there’s an innocent explanation, be ready for it to be tested against the wider pattern of your conduct.
You can dispute how a remark has been characterised while still recognising how your colleague experienced it. In Sawati v GMC [2022] EWHC 283 (Admin), the court said maintaining your innocence shouldn’t automatically be treated as a lack of insight. Showing you understand the impact, without conceding facts you dispute, is a delicate balance to strike.
Expect charges to be framed as sexual harassment, sexual motivation or both. And take advice before you respond. Early input from a defence organisation, a representative body or specialist healthcare regulatory defence lawyers can shape how the case unfolds.
Humour has a place in healthcare. But once it turns sexual, regulators look at the effect as closely as the intent, and “only banter” carries very little weight.
