As sustainability grows in importance, companies use Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) frameworks to guide operations. Within this context, materiality assessments have become essential tools for identifying and prioritizing the most significant ESG issues. Traditionally, materiality assessments focused solely on financial materiality—how environmental and social issues impact a company’s economic performance.
However, double materiality has emerged as a more holistic approach, considering financial and societal impacts. This article offers a step-by-step guide for conducting double materiality assessments to align with sustainable practices.
What is Double Materiality
Double materiality is an advanced concept in Global ESG mentoring that goes beyond the traditional financial materiality framework. It incorporates two dimensions: financial materiality and environmental/social materiality.
- Financial Materiality: This dimension focuses on problems that affect a company’s financial performance. For example, climate change can affect a company’s bottom line. It may lead to higher operational costs and increase regulatory compliance expenses.
- Environmental/Social Materiality: This dimension examines how a company’s operations impact the environment and society. For instance, a company’s carbon emissions, waste management practices, or labour policies may not immediately affect its financial statements but can significantly impact the planet and community.
By considering both aspects, companies can create a more comprehensive ESG strategy.
Steps to Conduct Double Materiality Assessment
-
Step 1: Define the Scope and Objectives
Before starting a double materiality assessment, define the scope and objectives. Start by identifying relevant stakeholders such as employees, customers, investors, suppliers, regulators, and local communities to understand their concerns and expectations. This will help determine which ESG issues are most pertinent.
Next, set clear objectives for the assessment, whether improving sustainability reporting, enhancing risk management, or meeting regulatory requirements as these will guide the entire process.
-
Step 2: Conduct a Stakeholder Analysis
Engaging stakeholders is crucial for a thorough double materiality analysis. Use surveys, interviews, focus groups, and workshops to gather their insights and understand which ESG issues they deem most important. Not all stakeholders will have the same level of influence or concern.
So prioritise them based on their impact on your business and interest in specific ESG topics. This approach ensures that your assessment reflects the views and expectations of all relevant parties.
-
Step 3: Identify Relevant ESG Issues
After understanding your stakeholders’ concerns, the next step is to check the most relevant ESG issues for your business. Start by reviewing industry standards and guidelines, such as those from the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI) and the Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB), to pinpoint common ESG issues in your sector.
Benchmark against peers by analysing the ESG reports of competitors and industry leaders to spot trends and relevant issues. Finally, conduct an internal assessment to identify existing and potential ESG risks and opportunities by examining your company’s operations, supply chain, and overall business model.
-
Step 4: Assess Financial Materiality
The first dimension of double materiality is financial materiality, which involves evaluating how ESG issues could affect your company’s performance. Begin with a risk assessment by analysing how each issue might pose a risk to your business, such as increased operational costs from regulatory changes on carbon emissions.
Next, assess potential opportunities, like how investing in renewable energy could reduce long-term costs and boost your company’s reputation. Where feasible, quantify the financial impact by estimating cost savings from energy efficiency measures or revenue potential from sustainable products.
-
Step 5: Assess Environmental and Social Materiality
The second dimension of double materiality involves evaluating how your business impacts the environment and society. Start with an environmental impact assessment by analysing factors such as your carbon footprint, water usage, waste generation, and effects on biodiversity.
Next, conduct a social impact assessment to review labour practices, human rights, community engagement, and product safety. Unlike financial materiality, this dimension requires a longer-term perspective, considering how your business practices might affect future generations.
-
Step 6: Prioritize ESG Issues
After assessing financial and environmental/social materiality, the next step is to identify ESG issues by creating a materiality matrix. This matrix visually represents the significance of each issue, plotting financial materiality on one axis and environmental/social materiality on the other, to highlight the most critical issues from both perspectives.
Before finalizing these priorities, consult with key stakeholders. Share the matrix with them. Gather their feedback. Refine the priorities based on their input.
-
Step 7: Integrate Findings into Strategy
The ultimate goal of a double materiality analysis is to guide your business strategy and decision-making processes. Use assessment insights to update your ESG strategy. Set new sustainability goals, develop action plans, and reallocate resources to high-priority issues. Integrate these ESG issues into your overall business planning and risk management to mitigate risks and seize opportunities.
Additionally, enhance sustainability reporting by updating stakeholders through annual and sustainability reports, and other channels.
-
Step 8: Monitor and Review
A double materiality assessment is an ongoing process that requires continuous monitoring and periodic reviews to stay relevant and current. Regularly track your progress against the ESG goals and targets set during the assessment using key performance indicators (KPIs). Periodically review and update your materiality assessment to reflect changes in your business environment, stakeholder expectations, and regulatory requirements.
Maintain continuous engagement with stakeholders to stay informed about their evolving concerns and expectations, ensuring that your assessment addresses emerging ESG issues effectively.
Conclusion
Conducting a double materiality assessment helps businesses align with sustainable practices. It considers financial and environmental/social impacts to create a robust ESG strategy. Following the guide will help you prioritise key ESG issues, integrate them into your business strategy, and communicate effectively with stakeholders. As ESG’s importance grows, this assessment will be vital for navigating sustainability and achieving long-term success.