Hardness is a gemstone’s resistance to scratching, and toughness is its resistance to chipping and breaking. A stone needs enough of both for the kind of jewelry it goes into. Diamond is the hardest gem and jade is the toughest, and neither is best at everything. The chart below gives both ratings for 18 common jewelry stones.
Gemstone hardness scale: Mohs ratings for 18 jewelry stones
The gemstone hardness scale used in jewelry is the Mohs scale, which ranks minerals from 1 (talc) to 10 (diamond) by which one scratches which. Toughness has no everyday number, so the third column uses the plain ratings gemologists use.
| Gemstone | Mohs hardness | Toughness | Watch out for |
| Diamond | 10 | Good | A sharp blow at a thin edge can chip it |
| Ruby and sapphire | 9 | Excellent | Very little |
| Alexandrite (chrysoberyl) | 8.5 | Excellent to good | Very little |
| Spinel | 8 | Good | Very little |
| Topaz | 8 | Poor | Splits along one direction if knocked |
| Emerald | 7.5 to 8 | Poor to good | Internal fractures; most stones are oiled |
| Aquamarine | 7.5 to 8 | Good | Very little |
| Tourmaline | 7 to 7.5 | Fair | Hard knocks |
| Garnet | 6.5 to 7.5 | Fair to good | Varies by type |
| Amethyst and citrine (quartz) | 7 | Good | Slow surface wear over years |
| Jadeite | 6.5 to 7 | Exceptional | A hard drop onto tile or stone |
| Nephrite | 6 to 6.5 | Exceptional | Fine surface scratches from grit |
| Peridot | 6.5 to 7 | Fair to good | Scratches and sudden heat |
| Tanzanite | 6 to 7 | Fair to poor | Knocks and sudden temperature change |
| Moonstone | 6 to 6.5 | Poor | Knocks |
| Opal | 5 to 6.5 | Very poor to fair | Drying out, heat, knocks |
| Turquoise | 5 to 6 | Fair to good | Cosmetics, skin oils, chemicals |
| Pearl | 2.5 to 4 | Good | Scratches, perfume, acids |
What the Mohs scale measures and what it leaves out
The Mohs scale measures one thing: whether one material can scratch another. The German mineralogist Friedrich Mohs devised it in 1812 by lining up ten minerals so that each scratches the ones below it. A gem rated 8 scratches a gem rated 7 and is scratched by one rated 9.
The numbers are ranks, and the steps between them are uneven. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) notes that diamond, at 10, is many times harder than ruby and sapphire at 9.
For a jewelry buyer the most useful line on the scale is 7. Quartz has a hardness of 7, and fine quartz grit is part of ordinary household dust. A stone softer than 7 is scratched a little every time dust is wiped across it. Opal, turquoise and pearl lose their polish with daily wear for that reason, and sapphire keeps its polish for decades.
What the Mohs scale leaves out is breakage. A scratch test cannot predict what happens when a ring hits a door frame.
Hardness vs. toughness: why a diamond can chip
Hardness vs. toughness is a matter of two different kinds of damage. Hardness resists scratches. Toughness resists chips, cracks and breaks. Each depends on a different feature of the stone’s structure, so a gem can lead in one and sit in the middle in the other.
Diamond is the standard example. Its atoms are bonded so tightly that no other natural material scratches it, but the crystal has cleavage: flat planes along which it splits cleanly. A hard knock at the wrong angle, usually at a thin edge or a pointed corner, can take a chip out of it. Topaz is hard, at 8, and cleaves even more easily, which is why its toughness is rated poor.
Jade is the opposite case. Jadeite and nephrite rate only 6 to 7, close to quartz, and grit can mark their polish. But neither is a single crystal. Each is a mass of tiny crystals locked together: interlocking grains in jadeite, matted fibers in nephrite. A crack has no straight path to follow, so it stops after a short distance.
GIA puts figures on the difference. On the fracture-toughness values it cites, nephrite is listed at 225,000 and jadeite at 120,000, against roughly 5,000 to 8,000 for diamond.
What are the hardest gemstones?
The hardest gemstones are diamond at 10, ruby and sapphire at 9, and chrysoberyl, which includes alexandrite, at 8.5. Spinel and topaz follow at 8.
One lab-created material sits between the first two. Moissanite rates about 9.25 and is sold as a diamond alternative. The moissanite in jewelry is grown in a laboratory, because natural crystals are too small and too scarce to cut.
What are the toughest gemstones?
The toughest gemstones are the two jades. Nephrite is the toughest gem material in common use and jadeite is second. Among stones usually set in rings, ruby and sapphire come next: they have no cleavage and rate excellent.
Toughness is why jade was shaped into tools and blades in the Stone Age, long before it was worn as jewelry, and why it can be carved thin and pierced without falling apart.
If the question is limited to the four traditional precious stones, the toughest are ruby and sapphire. Emerald is the weakest of the four, because most emeralds contain fractures.
Stability: the third part of gemstone durability
Gemstone durability has a third part, stability, which is how well a stone stands up to heat, light and chemicals. GIA treats hardness, toughness and stability as the three factors and notes that no gem scores perfectly on all of them.
- Opal contains water and can craze if it dries out or is heated quickly.
- Pearl is attacked by acids, which include perfume and hairspray.
- Turquoise is porous and can discolor from cosmetics and skin oils.
- Emerald is usually filled with oil or resin, which heat and ultrasonic cleaners can remove.
Gemstone hardness questions
What is harder, sapphire or ruby?
Sapphire and ruby are equally hard. Both are the mineral corundum and both rate 9 on the Mohs scale. Red corundum is called ruby, and every other color is called sapphire.
Can a diamond break?
A diamond can chip or break. Its hardness protects it from scratches, but the crystal splits along cleavage planes when it is struck hard at the wrong angle. Pointed shapes and thin edges are the usual places for damage.
Is jade harder than diamond?
Jade is not harder than diamond. Jade rates 6 to 7 on the Mohs scale and diamond rates 10, so a diamond scratches jade easily. Jade is tougher than diamond, which means it is harder to chip or break.
What is the hardest gemstone after diamond?
The hardest natural gemstones after diamond are ruby and sapphire, at 9. Lab-created moissanite, at about 9.25, falls between them and diamond.
Which gemstones are too soft for an everyday ring?
Soft gemstones that struggle in a ring worn every day are opal, turquoise, pearl, moonstone and tanzanite. All rate below 7, so household dust scratches them, and several also chip easily. The same stones last far longer in earrings and pendants.
Does a harder gemstone cost more?
A harder gemstone does not cost more because of its hardness. Price follows rarity, color, clarity and size. Quartz is harder than jadeite and opal and sells for a small fraction of the price of fine examples of either.
Which gemstones suit rings, bangles, pendants and earrings?
Gemstones for rings and bangles need the most durability, because those pieces take the knocks, while pendants and earrings rarely touch anything.
| Piece | What it faces | Stones that cope | Better kept for occasional wear |
| Everyday ring | Knocks and constant abrasion | Diamond, ruby, sapphire, spinel, alexandrite, jadeite | Opal, pearl, turquoise, moonstone, tanzanite, emerald |
| Bangle carved from stone | Tables, door frames, counters | Jadeite, nephrite | Any brittle stone |
| Pendant | Little contact | Almost any stone | None |
| Earrings | Almost no contact | Almost any stone | None |
The bangle row is short for a reason. A bangle carved from one piece of stone has no metal around it, and it swings into hard surfaces all day. Very few gem materials are tough enough to be worn that way, and jade is the one that has been for centuries.
Repair records show what that toughness means in practice. BMjade, a jade workshop that handles its own after-sales repairs, says more than eight in ten of the knocked bangles it sees have only a small chip on an edge, between the size of a millet grain and a mung bean, and fewer than two in ten have broken through. The breaks, it says, come from two situations: a fall from about chest height flat onto tile or concrete, or a blow that finds a crack the bangle already had. The workshop also sees the two jades fail differently. Jadeite, the harder one, chips with a bright, glassy surface. Nephrite, the tougher one, more often shows a small bruise and keeps its edge. Small chips are ground smooth and repolished, and the bangle goes back on the wrist.
