Britain’s financial sector may be on the verge of yet another multi-billion-pound compensation scandal. This time, it involves overdraft refund claims. After the enormous payouts over PPI mis-selling, diesel emissions cheating, and hidden commissions on car finance, legal and consumer experts are warning that banks’ historical overdraft practices may expose them to huge liabilities.
For millions of consumers, overdrafts have become a routine part of managing finances, but many of those overdrafts may have been granted or extended without proper affordability checks. In simple terms, people were offered access to credit they couldn’t realistically afford to repay, pushing them deeper into financial hardship. This is a clear breach of lending rules that could now justify widespread claims for compensation.
Overdrafts: from emergency safety net to debt trap
Originally designed as a short-term facility to cover unexpected costs, overdrafts have slowly morphed into a permanent line of credit for many consumers.
Recent YouGov research (January 2024) indicates that around 30% of UK adults (nearly 16 million people) regularly dip into their overdraft. The UK’s total overdraft borrowing currently hovers around £2.7 billion.
For some households, overdrafts aren’t being used for one-off emergencies, but to cover day-to-day bills, food shopping, rent, and utilities. This is especially true for younger adults and those on lower incomes. Overdraft dependency has risen sharply since the Covid pandemic and cost-of-living crisis, with many households using overdrafts as a form of long-term borrowing, even though that was never their intended purpose.
The new payday loans?
While payday lenders faced intense regulatory crackdowns over the last decade, high street banks were quietly raising overdraft charges to levels.
In 2020, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) tried to simplify overdraft pricing by banning excessive fixed fees and aligning charges for both arranged and unarranged overdrafts. In theory, this reform was meant to make charges clearer and fairer. In practice, many banks simply replaced fees with very high interest rates.
Today, many UK banks (including Lloyds, Halifax, and Bank of Scotland) charge overdraft rates of up to 49.9% APR. According to Bank of England data, the average overdraft interest rate stands at 22.92%, more expensive than most credit cards and loans.
For many vulnerable borrowers, these eye-watering rates mean a simple overdraft can become an unaffordable long-term debt spiral.
What the banks did wrong: affordability rules
Under FCA rules, banks have a legal duty to assess affordability before offering credit, including overdrafts. The rules don’t just apply to loans and credit cards; any form of credit facility must be responsibly issued, with proper checks on the customer’s ability to repay without falling into financial hardship.
However, growing evidence suggests that for years, many banks routinely:
- Increased customer overdraft limits without verifying income or outgoings.
- Extended overdraft facilities to customers already struggling with existing debts.
- Allowed customers to remain heavily overdrawn for years without intervention.
This behaviour echoes precisely what triggered the PPI and payday lending scandals: consumers being offered unsuitable financial products they could not afford, resulting in significant long-term harm.
A systemic problem hiding for years
What makes the overdraft situation particularly dangerous for the banks is how long these practices may have gone unchecked.
One recent Financial Ombudsman case awarded a consumer £8,000 in refunds after a bank continually increased her overdraft limit over a decade without any affordability checks. The customer remained in persistent debt for years, with mounting interest charges causing serious financial stress.
In another major regulatory enforcement action, TSB was fined £10.9 million in 2023 and ordered to pay £99.9 million in redress to over 200,000 customers for failing to treat vulnerable customers fairly when managing overdraft debts.
Consumer finance experts are now warning that this is unlikely to be limited to just one or two banks; it may reflect widespread systemic failings across the entire sector, spanning over a decade.
Could this rival PPI or car finance claims?
The parallels with previous scandals are becoming increasingly hard to ignore.
- PPI claims cost banks over £50 billion in payouts after decades of widespread mis-selling.
- Diesel emissions claims have triggered lawsuits against major car manufacturers.
- Hidden commissions on car finance agreements are currently under Supreme Court scrutiny, with potential multi-billion pound liabilities looming for UK lenders. This could potentially top up redress due for Discretionary Commission Arrangements, which the FCA have already decided weren’t legal.
Overdraft refund claims may not yet have reached these headline-grabbing payout levels, but as public awareness grows, legal claims are expected to surge. The key legal argument is familiar: consumers were placed into long-term financial harm by credit being irresponsibly offered or extended, in violation of affordability and responsible lending rules.
How consumers can claim
If you believe your bank allowed you to run up an unaffordable overdraft without properly assessing your finances, you may be eligible for compensation.
There are two main routes:
1️⃣ Make a complaint directly to your bank:
You can approach your bank yourself, detailing why you believe your overdraft was unaffordable and that they failed to assess your ability to repay. You have to spend a bit of time on this, and it may affect your chance of success if not done properly.
2️⃣ Use a claims management company:
For consumers who don’t feel confident navigating the process, claims companies offer to handle the entire claim, preparing evidence, submitting complaints, and negotiating with the bank. However, they typically charge a success fee deducted from any compensation you receive.
While it’s entirely possible to submit your own complaint, many find that using a claims company simplifies the process and avoids mistakes that could result in rejected or undervalued claims.
A crisis in waiting?
Overdraft refund claims have the potential to become the next front-page financial scandal. The combination of widespread use, vulnerable customers, ultra-high interest rates, and questionable lending practices creates a perfect storm, one that could easily mirror the scale and seriousness of PPI or car finance commission mis-selling.
For consumers, it offers the chance to recover thousands of pounds in wrongly charged overdraft fees. For banks, it threatens another painful reckoning over years of irresponsible lending practices.
OTS News on Social Media